New York Red Bulls vs. Charlotte MLS Picks | 10-25-2023

New York Red Bulls Vs. Charlotte Fc Wild Card 2023 Mls Betting Picks

Updated October 23, 2023By Dean Etheridge

The New York Red Bulls and Charlotte FC will clash in the opening Wild Card match of the 2023 MLS Cup Playoffs. The Red Bulls are favored to win, but Charlotte will come into the match full of confidence after seeing off Messi and co to clinch their place in the postseason. The winners will face FC Cincinnati in Round One, and here we tell you the best bets to make in our latest MLS soccer betting picks.

New York Red Bulls Vs. Charlotte Fc Wild Card 2023 Mls Betting Picks

What; 2023 MLS

Who; New York Red Bulls vs. Charlotte FC

Where; Red Bull Arena, Harrison, New Jersey

When; Wednesday October 25th, 2023

Kick-Off; 7.30 pm ET

What an end to the regular season we witnessed on Saturday. Decision Day never fails to disappoint, and this year was no different. As a result of the last-day results, the postseason is now locked in, and the two Wild Card matches see the Red Bulls take on Charlotte, with Sporting Kansas facing San Jose in the second match.

It’s the matchup between the New York Red Bulls and Charlotte that we are focusing on, but first, let’s take a look at the latest betting to win the 2023 MLS Cup. 

Betting to win 2023 MLS Cup

FC Cincinnati await the winners of the Red Bulls vs Charlotte, and they are also the betting favorites to win the 2023 MLS Cup. The best MLS betting sites make Cincinnati +333 on the money line to win the trophy for the first time in their history.

Following behind Chris Albright’s team is the defending Champions, Los Angeles FC, who are +600. St. Louis, at +650, makes up the leading three contenders. 

Orlando City is +1000, with the two-times winner Columbus Crew at +1200, which is the same odds as a lot of people’s pre-season favorites, the Philadelphia Union. For the record, the Red Bulls are +5000, and Charlotte is +6600. Now, let’s take a look at the match betting.

New York Red Bulls vs Charlotte FC Betting Odds

The New York Red Bulls have the home-field advantage, and this has helped make them heavy favorites to win this match. The bookmakers make the Red Bulls -163 to win on the money line. A draw is next at +300, with Charlotte FC at +400 to take the honors. This is all 90 minutes of betting only.

In the props markets, the yes for both teams to score is -154, with a no at +110. Over 2.5 goals is -154, with under 2.5 at +110. For even more goals, over 3.5 is +188. The odds suggest that the best soccer betting sites expect goals.

Full-match betting is available below on our odds table. You can read more information about the sites our odds are taken from on our best online sportsbook reviews page.

New York on three-match winning streak

The Red Bulls seem to have found a bit of form at exactly the right time of the season. They’re on a winning streak of three and have won four of their last five. If you take their form back further, they have lost only one of their last seven.  

New York clinched their place in the playoffs in the most dramatic way possible. In a game that looked destined to be a stalemate, John Tolkin somehow held his nerve to win the match with a 94th-minute penalty kick away at Nashville. The goal and victory mean New York has qualified for the playoffs in 14 consecutive seasons, an MLS record. 

The Crowns are unbeaten in four

Charlotte also finished the season strongly with three wins and one draw from their final four matches. 

They clinched their first-ever playoff spot with a 1-0 win over Lionel Messi’s Inter Miami on Decision Day. Kerwin Vargas scored the winner after thirteen minutes. But the match was far from plain sailing as The Crowns had to rely on goalkeeper Kristijan Kahlina’s heroics to keep Miami at bay and secure their place in the postseason. 

Our Picks

The best MLS postseason betting sites are suggesting this match will have goals. And although we would love nothing more than a goal-fest, we are not convinced. 

In their last five games, over 2.5 has come in three times for matches involving New York. 

One game had eight goals, two had three, and two had one. For Charlotte, over 2.5 goals have been covered three times in their last five fixtures. One match had four, two had three, and two were under. 

Despite this, we feel this could be an edgy affair. And this means under 2.5 is the best bet. At odds against it, it is a good value bet at +110.  

Under 2.5 GoalsRed Bulls vs. Charlotte


Bet Now

We also think a tight win for New York could be the way to go on the money line for our match-winner pick. It looks set to be a close game, and New York has the added home-field advantage. If the money line is too short, then take the Red Bulls to win either 1-0 or 2-0. 

New York Red BullsTo beat Charlotte


Bet Now

Check below for our list of the top sportsbooks where you can wager online:



​New York Red Bulls vs Charlotte FC


Red Bull Arena,Harrison,New Jersey

Starting on

October 25, 2023

Ending on

October 25, 2023

About the Author

Dean Etheridge

Dean Etheridge

Over the last 10 years, Dean has sharpened his expertise in crafting and revising content for his soccer and cricket betting platforms. Driven by his passion for sports betting and writing, he embarked on a journey of writing about sports wagering.

Although Dean’s preferred areas of focus are the English Premier League and cricket, his extensive sports knowledge enables him to tackle nearly any sport.

Gone are the days of traveling the world to witness events like FIFA World Cups and Ashes cricket, as Dean now prefers the comfort of his own home while enjoying sports.

Read Dean’s Profile

Ask Dean about this guide:

Author: Richard Gonzales